I have always been enamored with San Francisco. I grew up just two hours away in Oakdale, a small Central Valley town. My family used to take trips to the city to do touristy things and take in Giants games. I remember thinking San Francisco was a very different world – one I wanted to be a part of.
Fast forward to fall, sometime in the mid-1990s. I was living in the East Bay and decided I was long past due for an apartment of my own in the city. No more roommates.
I had recently secured a job with Flying Dutchman Park, Inc., a company that managed parking lots and provided valet parking for private parties and restaurants. I worked in North Beach at a parking lot on the corner of Broadway and Kearny.
Other than finding an apartment, my objective was to get in a band, finish college, and meet girls. Working in North Beach on the weekends was a great way to accomplish two out of three, which at the time was productive enough for me. After work, I would often take in jazz at Pearls or check out rock bands at Club Cocodrie. My late hours and the fact that I was a musician made it easy to meet women.
I soon became seriously smitten with the Bettie Page doppelganger working at the Garden of Eden, a legendary strip club across the street from the parking lot. Her name was Angie, and I was quickly corrected that she was just a door girl, not a stripper. She dug my greasy pompadour and adored my 1965 Dodge Coronet. We quickly became an item.
My apartment search was proving to be a challenge. I spent a lot of time crashing at Angie’s place at 1140 Sutter Street in the Polk Gulch section of the city. The realtors called this area “lower Nob Hill,” hoping to distract potential renters from the area’s close proximity to the notoriously seedy Tenderloin district. The Polk Gulch had the colorful distinction of being the heartbeat of the LGBT community before it shifted to the Castro district in the 1970s. I fell in love with the Gulch and its ageless metropolitan vibe.
I ended up living with Angie and her sister for about a month while I looked for the perfect place of my own. Eventually, an apartment a few buildings down became available, in a 1911 building at 1114 Sutter. It was a tiny, dingy studio at $525 a month. I took it.
My new apartment was really close to Angie’s, so I was still a fixture at her place. She and her sister were creeped out by the odd behavior of the neighbor across the hall in apartment 304. They would often spy on him through their peephole as he stood in the hall and stared at their front door. It looked like he was going to knock but couldn’t quite find the courage. They often joked about the “curse” of apartment 304. My curiosity was piqued.
The apartment manager mentioned that the sunny one-bedroom seemed to attract peculiar types who didn’t stay long. I soon discovered that this “cursed” apartment was the one-time home of serial killer David Carpenter, otherwise known as the Trailside Killer.
David Carpenter was born on May 6, 1930 to Elwood and Francis Hart Carpenter. Elwood was a mean-spirited, physically and mentally abusive alcoholic. Francis was also abusive, but seemed to be more engaged in David’s life.
Carpenter spent most of his childhood at 152 Sussex Street in San Francisco’s Glen Park district. Glen Park is located south of Diamond Heights and Noe Valley, west of Bernal Heights, and east of Glen Canyon Park. The neighborhood is known for having a village-like atmosphere, with mom-and-pop shops, quality schools, and sheltered homes on hilly, narrow streets. Families that resided in Glen Park usually knew each other and their children often played together. It was in this idyllic environment that the Trailside Killer came into being.
Carpenter described his childhood as “hellish.” He took violin and ballet lessons, which made him the target of bullies. There were also rumors at school that David’s parents beat him, and classmates often noticed bruises on his body. He had a severe stutter and was a chronic bed-wetter. He also discovered early on that he had a ravenous, unhealthy sexual appetite that would often lend itself to compulsive, deviant behavior.
As an outlet for his inner turmoil, Carpenter tortured animals. When his father deserted the family for a year when he was 14, his erratic behavior escalated. He lured two sisters into a restroom in Diamond Heights Park, threatened them with a knife and began to get grabby. He was charged with molestation, and committed to Napa State Hospital for 90 days.
As a result of the Diamond Heights incident, David made an important discovery: During the attack, when he was in complete control, his stutter disappeared. This revelation into his inner-workings gave him confidence, and would shape the rest of his creep career.
In the mid 1950s, Carpenter joined the U.S. Coast Guard and eventually landed a job with Pacific Far East Lines as a purser on a long freighter named the Fleetwood. During this time he met and courted Ellen. The couple married on November 5, 1955, and settled down at 380 Mina Lane in the sleepy seaside town of Pacifica, just south of San Francisco. They had three children. At first life seemed stable, but eventually the union became fraught with tension. David was sexually demanding and prone to enraged outbursts.
The couple had a mutual friend, Lois DeAndrade, who also did accounting work for David’s father, Elwood. One day, Carpenter offered Lois a ride to work. He had been circling the block like a shark waiting for her to arrive at her bus stop. At first, she politely declined, but at his insistence, eventually accepted. She always got weird vibes from David, but assured herself he was just trying to be nice. What harm could possibly come from accepting a ride from a friend?
A sweaty, rapey Carpenter insisted on taking a detour so that Lois could see his newborn baby. Oddly, Carpenter then claimed he was having trouble locating his wife and child. As they drove into the Presidio, things began to take a bizarre turn. David parked and began making sexual advances toward Lois. When she rebuffed him, he exclaimed, “I have this fuming quirk that’s got to be satisfied!” He attacked her with a hammer as she screamed for help. A military policeman, Jewell Wayne Hicks, heard the commotion and recued Lois. She was critically injured but alive.
On April 2, 1961, David Carpenter was sentenced to 14 years at McNeil Island Prison in Washington, near Puget Sound. Back in San Francisco, Ellen Carpenter filed for divorce.
Nine years later, Carpenter was released from prison after serving his time for bashing the brains of Lois DeAndrade. As part of his parole, Carpenter began attending a group therapy class where he met Helen. The two dated for a short time before marrying and moving into 1140 Sutter Street in San Francisco. So began the curse of apartment 304.
In 1970, exasperated with David’s persistent need for sex, Helen took a vacation. Unable to control his compulsive sexual proclivities, Carpenter attacked a 19-year-old girl near Boulder Creek in the Santa Cruz Mountains. David was familiar with the area; his relatives had a cabin nearby that he used to visit as a child. The girl was able to escape, but her injuries required a stay in the hospital. She remembered his license plate number and physical description, and quickly gave the information to local police.
Meanwhile, David Carpenter continued his lustful, violent indulgences. He returned to 1140 Sutter Street, where he ditched his car, quickly changed clothes, slipped out the back door, and thumbed it to Santa Cruz.
In Santa Cruz, he promptly abducted two women, raped one, and insisted they drop him off outside Oakdale, which was nearly 100 miles away. Police eventually caught him buying a ticket at the Greyhound bus station in downtown Modesto. He was booked into the Stanislaus County jail.
The drama continued as Carpenter escaped jail with four other inmates, but was captured soon after. Eager for notoriety, Carpenter reportedly told his newfound jail homies that he just might be the Zodiac Killer.
He was transferred to Vacaville State Prison later that year, where it was determined that he had a 125 IQ, which is notably high. Prison doctors also diagnosed a behavioral disorder that manifested itself as a deep hostility and resentment toward women. Big surprise. He was released from prison in 1977, only to return to serve two more years for a parole violation.
On May 21, 1979, David Carpenter was once again released from prison. He settled into Reality House West, a halfway house in the ramshackle Tenderloin district.
He made an attempt at a normal life by attending a vocational rehabilitation program and securing a job with Gems of the Golden West, a company that sold key chains and trinkets. In retrospect, this probably wasn’t the best occupation for him – it allowed unsupervised, long-distance travel in the company van in the still somewhat carefree seventies. But David was determined to change. He began going to a speech therapist to work on his stutter, and joined the Sierra Club, which regularly hiked the trails of neighboring Mount Tamalpais.
Unfortunately, his compulsions resurfaced and he found it difficult to resist his overwhelming urges. The accountability factor of living at the halfway house started to cramp his style, so he moved in with his parents at 38 Sussex Street in old, familiar Glen Park. He enjoyed the privacy of living alone on the first floor of the house, where he could discreetly come and go without his pesky parents spoiling all the fun.
Thus began a six-week period that resulted in one of the most prolific killing sprees in California history. Here are some of his known victims:
Edda Kane was a Bank of America executive, wife, and proud member of the Nature Friends Tourist Club. On August 19, 1979, she decided to go hiking alone on Mount Tamalpais. Later that evening, when she failed to return from her hike, her husband alerted the authorities. She was found the next afternoon by a search dog, crouched down in a kneeling position with a large-caliber bullet wound in the back of her head. She was 44.
Barbara Schwartz, age 23, was an organic bread maker living near Muir Beach on the beautiful Northern California coast. On March 8, 1980, while hiking alone on Mount Tamalpais near Bootjack Camp, she was attacked and stabbed repeatedly with what was described as a long, sharp blade. A witness to the horrific episode pleaded with Carpenter to stop before she fled the scene and called police.
During the commotion, Carpenter cut his hand so badly that he needed medical attention, so he drove 35 miles to Peninsula Hospital in San Mateo. The hospital staff smelled a rat when he gave the unlikely story that he was injured apprehending a suspect involved in a 7-11 robbery in Burlingame. Police questioned him, but ended up releasing him later that evening.
All this perverse activity still wasn’t enough to satisfy Carpenter. He began to stalk an attractive part-time bank teller at his neighborhood Continental Savings and Loan. The exuberant 17-year-old Anna Kelly Menjivar mesmerized David. She was young, beautiful, and way out of his league. He would often lurk around the bank trying to find out if she was working. If so, he would make small, meaningless transactions, often several times on the same afternoon. Anna’s mother recalled speaking to Carpenter outside the bank one day. From her perspective, Anna was being nice to the graceless Carpenter because she felt sorry for him.
The following afternoon, a woman approached the bank manager and expressed her concern for Anna after witnessing her chatting with Carpenter outside the bank. She distinctly remembered David Carpenter as the man who attacked Lois DeAndrade with a hammer in the Presidio back in 1960. In an effort to placate the woman, the bank manager assured her of Anna’s safety and thanked her for her concern.
Anna Kelly Menjivar disappeared on December 28, 1980. After a few days, police left open the possibility that she was a runaway, but her mother scoffed at the idea. Anna was a responsible young woman, looking forward to going to college and one day getting married. Her mother also noted that no money had been withdrawn from her bank account. On June 16, 1981, two hikers in Castle Rock State Park in the Santa Cruz Mountains found what they believed to be a human jawbone. Dental records proved the remains were those of Anna Menjivar.
The horror continued. Nineteen-year-old Richard Stowers and the love of his life, 18-year-old Cindy Moreland, decided to go for a hike near Point Reyes on a balmy Saturday morning in October of 1980. They never returned. The distraught families of both victims thought this behavior was out of character for the couple, as they were all very close and communicated frequently.
On November 29, their remains were located off Sky Trail on the National Seashore. Cindy had rope burns on her neck and semen around her pubic area. Both had been shot in the head.
Death seemed to permeate the air on that tranquil Indian Summer day, as the nude bodies of two more women, Diane O’Connell, 22, of Queens, New York, and Shana May, 22, of Pullman, Washington were found less than half a mile from Moreland and Stowers. O’Connell was found with her panties stuffed in her mouth and ligature marks around her neck. Both had been shot in the head.
Things finally began to unravel for Carpenter when he killed Ellen Hanson, 29, a U.C. Davis graduate, and attempted to kill her friend Steven Haertle. Steven survived after being shot four times. He later positively identified Carpenter as the triggerman.
David Carpenter’s final known act of savagery involved his friend Heather Skaggs, a 20-year-old blonde who attended the same trade school as Carpenter. She found him a bit awkward, but that didn’t stop her from accepting the occasional ride home. She needed a car of her own, if for no other reason than to thwart Carpenter’s clumsy efforts to make sure she got home safely. David informed Heather he had a car hook-up with a friend in Santa Cruz. Excited by the prospect of owning a car, she agreed to accompany him.
Friday, May 2, 1981 was the last time anyone saw Heather Skaggs. Her badly decomposed body was found with a gunshot wound to the head on May 24 in Big Basin Redwoods Park in the Santa Cruz Mountains.
The trial of David Carpenter was moved to San Diego County in order to avoid unnecessary media attention. He was found guilty on all counts and sentenced to death row in San Quentin, where he remains to this day. Investigators speculate that he may be responsible for several other murders, but he isn’t talking. He has appealed his convictions and asserts his innocence, of course.
In 2010, Carpenter was linked through DNA to another horrific crime: the decades-old death of Mary Francis Bennett, 23, who lived in San Francisco’s Sunset District. She went jogging one morning near Land’s End and never returned. On October 21, 1979, her body was found near the Legion of Honor. She had been stabbed over 25 times and buried beneath a shallow layer of dirt and branches.
I used to retrace Carpenter’s route out the back door of 1140 Sutter into the alley and feel a little sick to my stomach. Old buildings are often haunted by unspeakable events that took place inside their dusty walls. I’ve often wondered if the bad energy emanating from David Carpenter stayed to curse apartment 304.
Angie and I eventually went our separate ways. After dating for close to a year, she started seeing someone new. I was crushed. I used to see her around the neighborhood as late as 2005, but last I heard she moved to Los Angeles. Strangely enough, whenever I pass that old building I don’t think about Angie, I think about the Trailside Killer.
Graysmith, Robert The Sleeping Lady: The Trailside Murders Above the Golden Gate (1990) Dutton New York ISBN 0525247793
Weirde Dr. Dr. Weirde’s Weirde Tours: A Guide to Mysterious San Francisco (1994) Barrett and James Books ISBN 0964355906
Woodward, Boston The Prison Press: Conversations with David Carpenter, aka “The Trailside Killer” (2013)
Mitchell, David Sparsely, Sage and Timely (blog) www.sparselysageandtimely.com
Derbeken, Jaxon Van DNA ties Trailside Killer to 1979 SF Slaying (2010) SF Gate http://www.sfgate.com